Composite vs steel toe boots: Which is best for safety?

Choosing the right safety boots is key to staying safe on the job.

With so many options, it’s not always easy to decide between composite toe boots and steel toe boots.

Both types offer solid protection, but which one is right for you?

Let’s compare the two to help you make the right choice.

WHAT ARE COMPOSITE TOE BOOTS AND STEEL TOE BOOTS?

Composite toe boots

Composite toe boots use non-metallic materials like Kevlar, carbon fibre, or fibreglass for toe protection.

These materials are lighter and more flexible than steel, helping you feel more comfortable during long hours at work.

Steel toe boots

Steel toe boots are made with a reinforced cap at the toe for added strength and protection.

They’re known for their durability, ability to withstand heavy impact, and are often a more affordable option.

COMPOSITE SAFETY BOOTS VS STEEL TOE: KEY DIFFERENCES

Your safety at work starts with the right boots, know the differences before you decide.

While both types of boots conform to EN 20345:2022+A1:2024 safety standards, only composite toe safety boots are non-conductive as they don’t contain metal, making them safe for electrical work.

However, they can be more expensive. If you’re not working around electrics, a steel toe boot is a more affordable option that offers strong impact protection.

If you’re working in a wet or humid environment, opting for composite toe boots is the best option as they are less prone to rusting.

Which boot is more comfortable?

The lighter weight of composite boots means less strain on your legs and feet, reducing fatigue, especially if you're on your feet all day.

Unlike steel, composite boots don't conduct heat or cold, keeping you more comfortable in colder working environments.

Which boot is cheaper?

Composite boots can be pricier due to the materials used and manufacturing techniques. But, for workers around electrical hazards or in need of lightweight boots, they often justify the cost.

Which boot is more sustainable?

The non-metallic materials used in composite toes often have a lower environmental impact during production. They’re also easier to recycle and repurpose at the end of their life.

COMPOSITE SAFETY BOOT: PROS AND CONS

PROS:

• Lightweight - helps reduce fatigue over long shifts.
• Non-conductive - safe to wear around electrical hazards.
• Non-metal – ideal for those working in airports.
• Warms up faster - more comfortable in cold environments.
• Rust-free - better suited to wet or humid conditions.
  

CONS:

• Higher cost - composite materials and design can cost more.
• Less impact-resistance - not as strong as steel.

STEEL TOE BOOT: PROS AND CONS

PROS:

• Maximum impact protection - tough and reliable.
• Affordable - often cheaper than composite boots.

CONS:

• Heavier material - tiring if you’re on your feet all day.
• Conducts heat and cold - uncomfortable in extreme conditions.
• Conducts electricity - not suitable for electrical work.
• Can rust - not ideal for damp or wet environments.

WHAT’S THE BEST SAFETY BOOT FOR YOU?

Choosing the right safety boots fully depends on your working environment.

If you’re around electrical hazards, composite boots are ideal. For maximum durability and impact protection, steel toe boots are a solid choice.

Not sure which boot to go for? 

SMI partners with trusted brands like ROKWEAR® and V12, which means that you get quality built to last.

Click here to shop our full range of safety boots!